Interactive projector vs interactive display - Which is better?
Interactive projector vs interactive display – which is better? This is a question many schools and education providers are asking when considering interactive technologies for the classroom.
Both devices have pros and cons, education providers must weigh up functionality, price, maintenance costs and the types of interactive learning that the devices will be used for. It can be tricky to decide whether a touch screen display or interactive projector is the best option, so let’s take a look first at the differences between the two.
What is an interactive projector?
An interactive projector comprises two parts; a whiteboard and projector which features a lens to project images. The projector is usually mounted to the ceiling or to the wall above the whiteboard and is the source of the content being displayed. The whiteboard acts as a plain screen to display the projected content.
Interactive projectors enable interaction by tracking movements, either by infrared or DLP technology.
Here’s how infrared works:
– A camera on the projector tracks the movement of an interactive pen
– The pen transmits infrared light to the camera when it makes contact with the whiteboard
– This movement is recorded and reflected in the projection itself
– Similar to how the movements of a wireless computer mouse are reflected on the PC screen.
How does a projector work? Here’s how DLP works:
– The projector emits patterns on top of the projected image
– Patterns occur quickly enough that they’re not detected by the human eye
– Interactive pen provided picks up on this pattern and relays it back to the projector
– Projector reflects the movements back to the touch screen whiteboard.
Some interactive projectors enable wireless projecting by connecting remotely to laptops, PCs or tablets. Others require wired connections. Essentially, however, even the best interactive projectors simply project what is on the connected computer.
What is an interactive touchscreen display?
Interactive displays are wall-mounted screens which display images while enabling touchscreen interaction. They are composed of only the display screen itself – and usually a remote control – and in many ways, they can be compared to tablets, only much, much larger.
Unlike interactive projectors, interactive panels don’t always require a pen for writing on the display image because they can respond to fingertip touch or palm touch. However, they often feature stylus pens to enable a natural writing experience that is similar to writing on a traditional whiteboard with a dry erase marker.
A huge benefit of interactive touch screens is that they don’t rely on the input of other laptops, PCs or tablets. Avocor displays use a Windows 10 interface and can be used just like any other Windows computer or tablet.
When additional sources are required, they can be connected to a USB port, or documents can simply be uploaded via a USB memory stick.
The functionality of interactive touch projector vs interactive display
Since touch displays act like computers in themselves and don’t require connection to other devices, they’re incredibly easy to set up and use with minimal training.
Avocor displays use Windows 10, which makes the interface highly familiar and intuitive for the majority of teachers and students. However, open platform capabilities also allow third-party hardware and software to be incorporated for increased flexibility.
Interactive projectors, by contrast, always rely on a computer connection. The more expensive models may enable a wireless connection to computers which improves convenience, but ultimately teachers are required to hook up their laptop to the projector every time it is in use.
By contrast, interactive displays are room-ready with no need to connect additional devices unless preferred.
While discussing functionality, it’s worth mentioning that interactive display boards are much quieter than projectors which rely on fans to function. Although the noise of the fans may not be excessive, they may cause irritation to students who are sensitive to noise, or they could distract from the teacher’s voice during lessons.
Image quality of interactive touch screens vs interactive whiteboards
One of the biggest downfalls of interactive projectors is image quality. Here’s why:
– Projected images tend to be less bright than of LED displays
– Dull images can result in eye strain for teachers and students
– Brightness and quality of the projection tend to diminish over time.
When comparing interactive touch screens vs interactive whiteboards, it’s important to note that the lamps found in the projectors themselves tend to require regular replacement. This can prove costly, particularly in schools which strive to include interactive technology in many classrooms.
Furthermore, it is usually necessary to lower blinds and turn off overhead lights to ensure the screen can be seen as clearly as possible, particularly when the image begins to degrade.
Sitting in dark classrooms is not an appealing idea for either teachers or students, which means that the touch screen projector may only be used for short periods of time. If an interactive projector cannot be used for the entirety of a lesson, it is unlikely that students will really experience the full benefits of an interactive classroom.
Although types of projectors for classrooms are in abundance, there really is very little competition between interactive display vs whiteboard and interactive projector when it comes to image quality. Displays can offer a crisp, colourful, high definition image that will not degrade over time in the same way that a classroom projector will.
Image brightness will not fade on an LED display, many models even allow screen brightness to be adjusted depending on the brightness of the room. This can help to minimise eye strain.
There’s never any need to replace lamps or other elements within an LED display, either, which makes them really easy and affordable to maintain.
Cost of interactive projector vs interactive display
When comparing initial purchase costs of interactive touch screens vs interactive whiteboards and projectors, displays tend to be more expensive. For schools on a budget, this can be off-putting when assessing the affordability of interactive technology.
However, projectors tend to be far less reliable than interactive displays, which can make them more expensive to maintain. Bear in mind the following factors:
- Lamps will require periodic replacement
- Warranties of replacement lamps tend to be just a few months
- Quality of replacement lamps tend to be lower than that of original lamps, thus diminishing image quality
These factors tend to mean that overall costs of an interactive display vs whiteboard and an interactive projector are around the same. Interactive displays require little to no maintenance since there are no parts that need frequent replacement.
It’s also vital to remember that the image quality of a projector will always diminish over time. Subsequently, while initial investment in the device was less than that of an interactive display, the investment does not stand the test of time in the same way.
For schools working to strict budgets, it makes sense to assess the longevity of technology to understand whether an investment is worthwhile. In the case of interactive projector vs interactive display, the display tends to be the more sensible investment despite the higher initial costs.
Interactive display vs whiteboard and interactive projector – which wins out?
For schools committed to improving interactive learning in the classroom, interactive display screens are certainly a wiser investment. Here’s why:
- Convenient, room-ready, and intuitive user interface
- Versatile functionality and compatibility with third-party hardware/software
- Crisp image quality
- Image quality does not degrade
- Bright display to minimise eye strain
- Silent operation (no fans)
- Minimal, low-cost maintenance